FC Cincinnati

• Portero
• 18 Roman Celentano
• Defensa
• 24 Kyle Smith
• 11 Samuel Gidi (91')
• 21 Matt Miazga
• Centrocampista
• 5 Obinna Nwobodo (73')
• 29 Bryan Ramírez
• 20 Pavel Bucha
• 22 Gerardo Valenzuela (82')
• Delantero
• 10 Evander Ferreira x2
• 17 Kenji Mboma Dem x2 (82')
• 9 Ahoueke Denkey (94')

• Banquillo
• ent Pat Noonan 3-4-2-1
• 66 Ender Echenique (82')
• 27 Brian Anunga (73')
• 13 Evan Louro
• 16 Tom Barlow (82')
• 4 Nick Hagglund (91')
• 55 Ayoub Lajhar
• 99 Ayoub Jabbari (94')
• 88 Andrei Chirila
• 3 Gilberto Flores

Orlando City

• Portero
• 71 Maxime Crépeau
• Defensa
• 4 David Brekalo
• 6 Robin Jansson
• 3 Adrián Marín (71')
• Centrocampista
• 24 Griffin Dorsey (71')
• 20 Eduard Atuesta
• 8 Braian Ojeda (84')
• 77 Iván Angulo
• Delantero
• 10 Martín Ojeda x2
• 22 Justin Ellis (56')
• 11 Tiago (45')

• Banquillo
• ent Martín Perelman 3-4-2-1
• 16 Wilder Cartagena (71')
• 14 Tyrese Spicer (45')
• 5 Luis Otávio (84')
• 19 Zakaria Taifi
• 87 Marco Pasalic (56')
• 12 Javier Otero
• 13 Duncan McGuire (71')
• 57 Iago Teodoro
• 29 Tahir Reid-Brown