Columbus Crew
- Portero
- 28 Patrick Schulte
- Defensa
- 4 Rudy Camacho
- 31 Steven Moreira 68'
- 25 Sean Zawadzki
- Centrocampista
- 23 Mohamed Farsi 77'
- 20 André Gomes
- 27 Max Arfsten 68'
- 17 Sékou Bangoura 81'
- Delantero
- 16 Taha Habroune 68'
- 8 Daniel Gazdag
- 10 Diego Rossi
- Banquillo
- ent Laurent Courtois 3-4-1-2
- 21 Yevhen Cheberko (68')
- 2 Andrés Herrera (77')
- 30 Hugo Picard (68')
- 14 Amar Sejdic (81')
- 1 Nicholas Hagen
- 90 Nariman Akhundzada
- 45 Owen Presthus
- 7 Dylan Chambost (68')
- 12 Cesar Ruvalcaba
Atlanta United FC
- Portero
- 1 Lucas Hoyos
- Defensa
- 55 Tomás Jacob
- 3 Elías Báez
- 4 Enea Mihaj
- 6 Juan Berrocal
- Centrocampista
- 8 Tristan Muyumba
- 35 Ajani Fortune
- 48 Cooper Sanchez
- 11 Saba Lobjanidze 68'
- 20 Luke Brennan 59'
- Delantero
- 59 Miranchuk
- Banquillo
- ent Gerardo Martino 4-1-4-1
- 28 Will Reilly
- 10 Miguel Ángel Almirón (59')
- 18 Pedro Amador
- 47 Matt Edwards
- 5 Stian Gregersen
- 42 Jayden Hibbert
- 2 Ronald Hernández
- 30 Cayman Togashi
- 19 Sergi Santos (68')